errorPlease register the sub image.

Selected Cases

Intellectual Property Rights,TIF(Tech · IP · Fintech)

Defending Four of Five Patent Claims Against an Invalidation Challenge by a Major Online Platform Company

  • Date 2026.11.13
  • Hit 82

ONE Law Partners' TIF Team represented a patent holder in patent invalidation proceedings initiated by a major online platform company concerning a mobile phone case patent. The team successfully defended four of the patent's five claims against invalidation, preserving key technical features of the patented invention.


1. Case Overview

The client holds a registered patent for a mobile phone case equipped with a credit card storage compartment. The patented technology includes a hinge mechanism connecting the main body of the phone case to a cover designed to protect the card storage compartment.

A major online platform company, which had been selling certain mobile phone cases, became the defendant in a patent infringement lawsuit filed by the client. The company subsequently initiated patent invalidation proceedings challenging the validity of the client's registered patent.

Relying on previously disclosed technologies relating to mobile phone cases and hinge mechanisms, the opposing party argued that Claims 1 through 5 of the patent lacked novelty or inventive step and should therefore be invalidated in their entirety.

In particular, the opposing party compared the structural features and hinge connection mechanisms disclosed in multiple prior art references, asserting that the client's patented invention could have been readily conceived by a person skilled in the art.

ONE Law Partners' TIF Team represented the patent holder in these proceedings, analyzing the technical features of each patent claim and developing arguments focused on the differences between the claimed invention and the cited prior art, as well as the inventive step of the patented technology.


2. Key Legal Issues

First, whether the hinge connection mechanism of the mobile phone case could have been readily derived from the prior art.

The patent concerned a mobile phone case comprising a separately formed main body and cover, connected through a hinge portion integrally formed with the main body and a fitting protrusion formed on the cover.

The opposing party argued that similar hinge and connection structures had already been disclosed in prior art relating to mobile phone cases and that the client's invention therefore lacked inventive step.

Accordingly, a key issue was to identify and analyze the specific structural differences between the hinge mechanisms disclosed in the cited prior art and those defined in the client's patent claims.

Second, whether the additional technical features of the hinge mechanism specified in the dependent claims possessed an inventive step.

Claim 2 of the patent further defined a specific hinge structure in which a portion of the main body is partially cut to form a separated portion and a connecting portion, thereby enabling the hinge function.

Claims 3 through 5 introduced additional limitations concerning the detailed configuration of the fitting groove, the material of the hinge portion, and the connection structure.

The central question was whether these additional technical features could be readily derived by a person skilled in the art, even where certain elements were shared with the prior art.


3. Legal Strategy and Representation

ONE Law Partners' TIF Team conducted a detailed comparison of the prior art references submitted by the opposing party with the patent claims and specification, focusing particularly on the distinctive technical characteristics of the hinge mechanism defined in the dependent claims.

First, the team emphasized the specific configuration of the hinge portion described in Claim 2 and its structural differences from the prior art.

Claim 2 was characterized by a structure in which a portion of the phone case's main body is partially cut to form a separated portion and a connecting portion, allowing part of the main body itself to function as a hinge.

In contrast, a principal prior art reference cited by the opposing party disclosed a hinge insert formed as a protruding structure on the side of the phone case.

The TIF Team highlighted this distinction, arguing that forming a hinge portion by partially cutting the main body itself was structurally different from simply providing a protruding hinge component on the exterior of the main body.

The team further emphasized that this configuration offered a technical advantage by utilizing part of the main body as the hinge mechanism, thereby reducing the number of separate components required.

The team also argued that the additional technical features of the dependent claims could not be readily derived through a simple combination of the cited prior art references.

The opposing party contended that the technical configurations of Claims 2 through 5 could be easily derived by combining multiple prior art references.

However, the TIF Team carefully distinguished the hinge structures, connection methods, and technical characteristics disclosed in each reference, arguing that the specific hinge configuration of the client's patent was neither disclosed in nor readily derivable from the cited prior art.

The Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (IPTAB) rejected the invalidation challenges against Claims 2 through 5.

The IPTAB recognized that the hinge structure defined in Claim 2 differed from the prior art because it was formed by partially cutting a portion of the main body itself.

In particular, the IPTAB determined that the protruding hinge insert disclosed in the prior art neither suggested nor implied the hinge structure defined in Claim 2. It also acknowledged the distinctive technical effect of reducing the number of components by utilizing part of the main body as the hinge mechanism.

Accordingly, the IPTAB concluded that the inventive step of Claim 2 was not negated by the cited prior art. It further determined that the inventive step of Claims 3 through 5, which directly or indirectly depended on Claim 2, was likewise not negated by the combinations of prior art asserted by the opposing party.

However, with respect to Claim 1, the IPTAB found that the differences from one of the prior art references amounted to a simple design modification that could be readily made by a person skilled in the art and therefore concluded that Claim 1 lacked inventive step.

As a result, on November 5, 2026, the IPTAB invalidated only Claim 1 and dismissed the invalidation challenges against Claims 2 through 5.

The IPTAB also ordered the opposing party, as the petitioner, to bear four-fifths of the trial costs.


4. Significance of the Case

This case demonstrates the importance of analyzing the technical features of individual patent claims and their differences from the prior art when defending against an invalidation challenge directed at an entire patent.

Although a major online platform company sought to invalidate all five claims of the registered patent, ONE Law Partners' TIF Team successfully defended four of the five claims by establishing the distinctive technical characteristics of the dependent claims.

In patent invalidation proceedings, novelty and inventive step may be assessed separately for each claim of a patent. Therefore, even where the inventive step of one claim is denied, other claims may remain valid if their additional technical limitations are distinguishable from the prior art.

In this case, a particularly important factor was the structural difference between a hinge component protruding from the exterior of a phone case and a hinge mechanism formed by partially cutting the main body itself.

The IPTAB recognized both this structural distinction and the technical advantage of reducing the number of separate components, concluding that the inventive step of Claims 2 through 5 was not negated by the cited prior art.


Through a thorough analysis of the prior art and detailed arguments concerning the technical distinctions of each claim, ONE Law Partners' TIF Team (formerly Minwho Law Firm) successfully defended four claims of the client's registered patent against invalidation, contributing to the protection of the client's intellectual property rights.
 


Contact

-
Kyung Hwan Kim | Attorney at Law
khkim@onelawpartners.com
-
ONE Law Partners | Public Relations Team
pr@onelawpartners.com


SNS Share 페이스북 공유하기트위터 공유하기네이버 공유하기