errorPlease register the sub image.

Selected Cases

Construction & Real Estate,Reconstruction & Redevelopment,Administrative Law

Victory at Trial and Appellate Levels in Action Seeking Revocation of Project Implementation Approval for Urban Renewal Redevelopment Project

  • Date 2026.11.19
  • Hit 82

One Law Partners, LLC represented a local government in a lawsuit seeking revocation of a project implementation approval for an urban renewal redevelopment project based on alleged procedural defects. The firm successfully demonstrated that a subsequent project implementation plan approval remedied any procedural defects in the previous approval and constituted a new administrative disposition that substantially modified key components of the project implementation plan. As a result, One Law Partners, LLC secured a dismissal of the action at first instance and dismissal of the plaintiff’s appeal at the appellate level



1. Overview of the Case
 
This case began when a landowner within an urban renewal redevelopment project district in Seoul filed a lawsuit against a local government seeking revocation of a project implementation approval.
 
The plaintiff argued that procedural defects existed in the original approval process because he had not received individual notice of the public inspection and public announcement required under the Urban and Residential Environment Improvement Act, thereby depriving him of a meaningful opportunity to submit his opinions.
 
Subsequently, the project implementers amended the original project implementation plan by changing the principal use of the building facilities from “urban-type housing” to “apartment housing” and establishing a new project implementation plan that adjusted the gross floor area, number of basement levels, parking capacity, and total project costs. The local government then issued a subsequent approval after satisfying the statutory consent requirements of landowners and completing the required public inspection, public notice, and opinion-hearing procedures.
 
The plaintiff nevertheless continued to seek revocation of the original approval, arguing that the subsequent approval was substantially identical to the original approval and therefore constituted a void administrative disposition issued in violation of the binding effect of a stay-of-execution order relating to the prior approval.
 
One Law Partners, LLC represented the local government and defended the litigation by focusing on the independence and legality of the subsequent approval, the extinguishment of the legal effect of the original approval, and the absence of any legal interest in challenging the original disposition.
 
 
2. Key Issues
 
First, the key issue was whether the subsequent project implementation plan approval constituted a new administrative disposition replacing the original approval.
 
The central question was whether the change in the principal use of the building facilities from urban-type housing to apartment housing was merely a minor modification or a substantial revision to a key component of the project implementation plan. In particular, it was necessary to consider the fact that changes in housing type affect applicable construction standards, housing supply regulations, project scale, and project costs.
 
Second, the issue was whether the procedural defects in the original approval had been cured through the subsequent approval.
 
The court was required to determine whether the alleged deficiencies in the original approval process, including the failure to provide notice of the public inspection and public announcement procedures and the lack of an opportunity to submit opinions, had been lawfully remedied during the subsequent approval process and, consequently, whether the original approval had lost its independent legal effect.
 
Third, the issue was whether the subsequent approval violated the binding effect of the stay-of-execution order relating to the original approval.
 
The plaintiff argued that the subsequent approval was intended to circumvent the stay-of-execution order and was therefore void. However, if the subsequent approval constituted a new and distinct disposition, a separate analysis was required as to whether it violated the binding effect of the prior stay order.
 
 
3. Key Response Strategy
 
One Law Partners, LLC conducted a detailed review of the Urban and Residential Environment Improvement Act and relevant Supreme Court precedents and argued that the subsequent approval constituted a new administrative disposition replacing the original approval.
 
The firm first emphasized that changing the principal use from urban-type housing to apartment housing was not merely a change in nomenclature but a substantive modification resulting in material differences in applicable laws, construction standards, and housing supply procedures.
 
In particular, the firm demonstrated that urban-type housing and apartment housing are governed by different requirements relating to noise mitigation measures, apartment building layout standards, emergency water supply facilities, and community facilities, as well as different housing-supply regulations, including subscription systems and price-cap regulations.
 
The firm further established that significant aspects of the project implementation plan had been substantially modified. The revised plan increased the gross floor area by approximately 1,700 square meters, representing an increase of approximately 3%, added one additional basement level, increased parking capacity by approximately 12%, and increased total project costs by approximately 13%.
 
In addition, the firm emphasized that no subsequent procedures based on the original approval, such as expropriation proceedings or management disposition planning, had been implemented and that the subsequent approval process involved newly conducted project-approval procedures, including consultations with the Central Land Tribunal and the solicitation of opinions from interested parties.
 
With respect to the procedural defects alleged in the original approval, One Law Partners, LLC demonstrated that the statutory consent requirements were satisfied during the subsequent approval process and that new public inspection, public notice, and individual notification procedures were conducted, thereby providing the plaintiff with a meaningful opportunity to submit opinions.
 
The firm further argued that the subsequent approval was not the execution or continuation of the original approval process. Rather, it was a separate administrative disposition issued after curing procedural defects and substantially revising key elements of the project implementation plan. Accordingly, it did not violate the binding effect of the stay-of-execution order relating to the original approval.
 
As a result, the trial court held that the subsequent approval replaced the original approval and that the plaintiff therefore lacked a legally protected interest in seeking revocation of the original disposition. The court accordingly dismissed the action.
 
When the plaintiff appealed, One Law Partners, LLC reinforced its arguments by highlighting the differences in the applicable legal framework resulting from the change in the principal use of the building, the substantial revisions to the project scale, the curing of procedural defects, and the governing legal principles concerning the binding effect of stay-of-execution orders.
 
The appellate court likewise held that the subsequent approval constituted a new administrative disposition that both substantially modified key aspects of the original project implementation plan and remedied the alleged procedural defects. The court further concluded that the subsequent approval was neither an execution of nor a continuation of the original approval process and therefore did not violate the binding effect of the stay-of-execution order.
 
Accordingly, the appellate court dismissed the plaintiff’s appeal, and One Law Partners, LLC achieved a successful outcome at both the trial and appellate levels.
 
 
4. Significance of the Case
 
This case provides important guidance regarding the criteria for determining whether a subsequent project implementation approval in an urban renewal redevelopment project constitutes a new administrative disposition replacing a prior approval.
 
In particular, it confirms that a change in the principal use of building facilities may be regarded as a substantial modification of a key component of a project implementation plan where it results in meaningful changes to applicable laws and regulations, construction standards, housing supply regulations, and the overall structure of the project, rather than merely constituting a physical design modification.
 
The case also confirms that where procedural defects in an original approval are lawfully cured through a subsequent approval and the original approval thereby loses its legal effect, a plaintiff may no longer possess the legal interest necessary to maintain an action seeking revocation of the original disposition.
 
Furthermore, the decision clarifies that the existence of a stay-of-execution order with respect to a prior administrative disposition does not necessarily preclude the issuance of a separate and independent new disposition designed to cure procedural defects.
 
One Law Partners, LLC successfully demonstrated the independence and legality of the subsequent approval through a comprehensive analysis of statutory provisions and judicial precedents governing urban renewal projects. By securing dismissal of the action at first instance and dismissal of the appeal at second instance, the firm effectively defended the lawfulness of the local government’s administrative actions and contributed to establishing a stable legal foundation for the continued implementation of the redevelopment project.
 
 
-
Yong-Rahk Shin, Attorney | yrshin@onelawpartners.com
Jeong-Ik Oh, Attorney | jioh@onelawpartners.com
Seong-Hoon Park, Attorney | shpark@onelawpartners.com
-
Public Relations Team, One Law Partners, LLC | pr@onelawpartners.com


SNS Share 페이스북 공유하기트위터 공유하기네이버 공유하기