errorPlease register the sub image.

Notices

Legal Information

[Attorney Column] Navigating the Military Sexual Grievance Review Committee: Resolution Procedures Through a Case Study N

  • Date 2026.11.17
  • Hit 13

ONE LAW PARTNERS LEGAL INSIGHTS

Military Cases · Case Study

Responding to a Military Sexual Grievance Review Committee: A Case Study

Elements of Sexual Harassment and Case Law, the Committee's Review Procedure, Its Relationship with Disciplinary Committees, Burden of Proof, and Liability for Damages

Recently, as the proportion of women has grown not only in ordinary workplaces but also in the military, cases of sexual grievances have been increasing. Sexual grievances in the military are assessed under the same standards as those in ordinary workplaces, but this article explains the procedures and standards by which they are handled in the unique setting of the military. The author recently represented the respondent in a sexual harassment report arising in the military, appeared before the Sexual Grievance Review Committee, and, through advocacy on whether the conduct constituted sexual harassment, obtained a finding that it did not .

 

1. The Concept and Legal Basis of Sexual Harassment

A. How Is Sexual Harassment Defined by Statute?


Sexual harassment is defined in several statutes, and their core elements are the same.

Article 3, subparagraph 2 of the Framework Act on Gender Equality defines sexual harassment as conduct by which "an employee of a state agency, local government or public organization prescribed by Presidential Decree, an employer or a worker, in a work, employment or other relationship, ① abuses his or her position or, in connection with work or the like, causes the other party to feel sexual humiliation or aversion through sexual words, actions or demands, or ② imposes a disadvantage on the other party for refusing to comply with sexual words, actions or demands, or expresses an intention to confer a benefit on condition of compliance" (Framework Act on Gender Equality, Article 3(2)).
 

Article 2, subparagraph 2 of the Equal Employment Opportunity and Work-Family Balance Assistance Act (the "Equal Employment Act") defines "sexual harassment in the workplace" as "an employer, superior or worker, by abusing his or her position in the workplace or in connection with work, causing another worker to feel sexual humiliation or aversion through sexual words or actions, or imposing a disadvantage in working conditions or employment on the ground that the worker did not comply with sexual words, actions or other demands." In addition, Annex 1 under Article 2 of the Enforcement Rule of the same Act sets out examples of criteria that give concrete form to this definition.

 

B. What Are the Elements of Sexual Harassment under Case Law?

 

The Supreme Court has established a consistent body of law on the elements of sexual harassment.
 

1) What are "sexual words and actions"?

"Sexual words and actions" means physical, verbal or visual conduct relating to physical relations between men and women or to the physical characteristics of men or women which, in light of the sound common sense and practices of society, could objectively cause an ordinary and average person in the same position as the other party to feel sexual humiliation or aversion (Supreme Court Decision 2020Da270503 (Nov. 25, 2021)). This includes not only cases where the victim is directly made to feel sexual humiliation or aversion, but also cases where an environment in which such feelings may arise is created indirectly, through other people or media (Supreme Court Decision 2021Da219529 (Sep. 16, 2021)).
 

2) No sexual motive or intent required

For sexual harassment to be established, the actor need not have had a sexual motive or intent (Supreme Court Decision 2017Du74702 (Apr. 12, 2018)).
 

3) Objective standard plus actual humiliation felt by the victim

Taking into account specific circumstances such as the relationship between the parties, the place and situation in which the conduct occurred, the express or presumed reaction of the other party, the content and degree of the conduct, and whether it was a one-time or short-term occurrence or a continuing one, there must be conduct that could objectively cause an ordinary and average person in the same position as the other party to feel sexual humiliation or aversion, and it must be established that the other party actually felt sexual humiliation or aversion as a result (Supreme Court Decision 2005Du6461 (Jun. 14, 2007); Supreme Court Decision 2017Du74702 (Apr. 12, 2018)).
 

4) Work-relatedness required

The requirement of "abusing one's position or in connection with work" denotes work-relatedness in a broad sense. It covers not only sexual words or actions taken on the occasion of, or by taking advantage of, the performance of work, but also those made by abusing authority or under the pretext of performing work. Whether particular sexual words or actions are work-related must be determined in light of specific circumstances, such as the relationship between the parties, the place and situation of the conduct, and its content and degree (Supreme Court Decision 2022Da273964 (Feb. 2, 2023); Supreme Court Decision 2021Da219529 (Sep. 16, 2021)). The courts also recognize workplace sexual harassment even for conduct outside the workplace or outside working hours, as long as the employer, superior or worker abused his or her position in the workplace or the conduct was work-related.
 

5) Gender sensitivity required

When hearing sexual harassment cases, courts must maintain "gender sensitivity" so as to understand issues of sex discrimination in the context in which the case arose and to realize gender equality (see Framework Act on Gender Equality, Article 5(1)). Taking into account that victims may be reluctant to testify or may report late out of fear of secondary victimization, courts must not lightly dismiss the probative value of a victim's statement (Supreme Court Decision 2017Du74702 (Apr. 12, 2018)).
 

6) Sexual shame not required

For sexual harassment to be established, it is sufficient that the other party felt sexual humiliation or aversion because of the actor's sexual words or actions; feeling sexual shame is not a requirement (Seoul High Court Decision 2020Nu68129 (Feb. 16, 2022)).

 

2. What Cases Have Courts Recognized or Rejected as Sexual Harassment?


A. Which Cases Have Courts Recognized as Sexual Harassment?

 
Case Conduct Grounds for Recognition
Supreme Court Decision 2007Du22498 (Jul. 10, 2008) A credit card company branch manager repeatedly hugged, kissed on the cheek or slapped the buttocks of eight female employees on 14 occasions Severe and repeated enough to worsen the working environment; abuse of the branch manager's superior position
Supreme Court Decision 2022Da273964 (Feb. 2, 2023) The head of news production at a regional broadcaster made sexual remarks and gestures toward a trainee producer Abuse of workplace position; work-relatedness recognized
Supreme Court Decision 2021Da219529 (Sep. 16, 2021) Spreading false sexual rumors about a female co-worker Indirectly creating an environment of sexual humiliation; work-relatedness recognized
Supreme Court Decision 2005Du13414 (Dec. 21, 2006) A provincial governor touched the chest of the head of a professional association during a meeting On the occasion or under the pretext of performing work; work-relatedness recognized
Seoul Administrative Court Decision 2021Guhap5024 (May 4, 2023) A police station's chief of investigations made sexual remarks to a trainee reporter and administered eye drops to her Work-relatedness recognized; victim's subordinate position taken into account
Daejeon High Court Decision 2026Nu187 (Aug. 20, 2026) Sexual remarks about the victim made to a third party (F), not to the victim Working in the same department; indirectly creating an environment of sexual humiliation
Changwon District Court Decision 2025Guhap1673 (Jul. 23, 2026) Repeatedly sending a subordinate KakaoTalk messages with comments on her appearance and personal feelings over one year and three months Repetition; victim received psychiatric treatment
Seoul Administrative Court Decision 2025Guhap56143 (Aug. 20, 2026) A team leader repeatedly made sexual remarks and gestures toward a subordinate Sexual harassment recognized; demotion upheld


B. Which Cases Have Courts Rejected as Sexual Harassment?

 
Case Conduct Grounds for Rejection
Supreme Court Decision 2005Du6461 (Jun. 14, 2007) An elementary school vice principal twice urged female teachers to pour drinks for the principal Most of the female teachers did not feel sexual humiliation; as a courtesy toward a superior, it was not objectively a sexual word or action
Uijeongbu District Court, Goyang Branch Decision 2023Gadan67749 (Apr. 25, 2024) At a company dinner, the defendant put his hand around the plaintiff's side and patted her back Plaintiff's claim dismissed; sexual harassment not recognized considering all circumstances
Chuncheon District Court, Gangneung Branch Decision 2021Guhap30823 (Aug. 18, 2022) While talking about past relationships in a car, saying "I held back back then" Disciplinary ground not recognized (plaintiff prevailed); insufficient to be regarded as conduct causing sexual humiliation or aversion

3. What Is the Review Procedure of the Military Sexual Grievance Review Committee?


A. Legal Basis and Nature of the Committee


The procedure for sexual grievance cases in the military is governed by the Framework Act on Gender Equality, the Directive on Unit Management (the "Directive") and the regulations of each armed service. The Sexual Grievance Review Committee (the "Committee") is a body that "reviews" sexual harassment and sexual violence cases, and its review is not a mandatory step that must precede disciplinary proceedings (Seoul High Court (Chuncheon Bench) Decision 2025Nu180 (Sep. 18, 2025); Seoul High Court Decision 2024Nu48864 (Apr. 17, 2025)).

 

B. How Does the Committee's Review Procedure Work?


1) The first step after an incident is separating the actor and the victim.

When a sex-related incident occurs, the Sexual Harassment Prevention and Response Center of each service first separates the perpetrator and the victim. This used to be called "perpetrator-victim separation," but is now called "actor-victim separation." Since no one has yet been investigated as a perpetrator at this stage, "actor" appears to be the more appropriate term. Separating the actor is the rule, and the actor and the victim must be separated first even before the facts are established (Directive on Unit Management, Article 250-3).
 

2) Investigation and victim protection measures proceed simultaneously.

Under the Directive, after receiving a request to investigate a sexual harassment or sexual violence case and verifying the necessary facts, the sexual grievance handling department may have the inspection (audit) department, an investigative agency or another department (or personnel) designated by the unit commander conduct the investigation, and must cooperate with the investigating department by providing relevant information and other necessary assistance. It must also notify the minimum number of commanders or related units necessary to handle the case. In addition, the Directive provides that a victim of sexual harassment or sexual violence may report directly to an investigative agency even if the gender equality chain of command has expressly objected, so that the case can move directly into criminal investigation (Directive on Unit Management, Article 250).
 

Each unit commander (or the next higher commander, if the unit commander is the actor) must block secondary victimization, such as undue pressure, persuasion or the spreading of rumors by the actor or third parties against the victim. From the time a report of sexual harassment, sexual violence or secondary victimization is made, the actor must not contact the victim or the victim's family in any way (including by telephone, text message or social media), whether directly or through a representative or family member. Any apology or offer of a civil or criminal settlement may be conveyed only through a representative such as the victim's attorney or through an investigator (Directive on Unit Management, Article 250-3).
 

During the handling of a sexual harassment or sexual violence case, the victim may request protective measures such as excluding interested persons from the process, health counseling and treatment of harm, and reassignment or transfer, and the commander of the unit handling the case may not refuse without justifiable grounds, such as an urgent operational need (Directive on Unit Management, Article 250-3).
 

3) The Committee convenes to determine whether sexual harassment is established.

Once the investigation is complete, the Committee must be convened to review whether sexual harassment or sexual violence is established, and, if necessary, it may be convened during or even before the investigation. Depending on the importance and urgency of the matter, written opinions may be used in place of a meeting. However, the Committee need not be convened where the investigation clearly establishes sexual harassment or sexual violence, or where there is an urgent need to commence disciplinary proceedings, for example because the actor's discharge is imminent (Directive on Unit Management, Article 251).
 

4) An attorney may participate and provide legal advice on the sexual grievance.

An attorney may be retained to represent either the victim or the actor (or perpetrator) before the Committee. In sex-related cases, however, facts may be withheld out of concern for secondary victimization, which can make effective representation of the actor difficult. In addition, as noted above, even when an apology or a civil or criminal settlement is offered, doing so through an attorney is the most appropriate way to prevent secondary victimization.

 

C. How Is the Committee Composed?


1) The number and gender of members must be fairly balanced.

The Committee consists of six or more members, including one chair. The internal members must include a military legal officer, at least two members must be appointed from among outside experts ("external members"), and under Article 21(2) of the Framework Act on Gender Equality, no single gender may exceed six-tenths of the appointed members. Where one gender exceeds 60% in violation of this rule, a defect in composition may be at issue (Seoul Administrative Court Decision 2025Guhap56143 (Aug. 20, 2026)). There is also a case holding, however, that such a defect in composition does not affect the validity of a disciplinary action unless the defect is serious (Seoul Administrative Court Decision 2025Guhap56143 (Aug. 20, 2026)).
 

2) Grounds for disqualification and members serving on both the Committee and the disciplinary committee

Where an outside expert who had previously counseled the complainant participates as a Committee member, the fairness of the review may be called into question, but there is a case in which a claim of procedural defect on that ground was not accepted (Changwon District Court Decision 2025Guhap1673 (Jul. 23, 2026)).

Whether the chair of the Committee's participation as a member of the personnel committee constitutes a ground for disqualification depends on whether that member is a direct victim of the conduct constituting the specific disciplinary ground (Seoul High Court Decision 2025Na207723 (Apr. 17, 2026)). By analogy, reference may also be made to the principle that a person who served as an investigating member of the Committee for Investigating Unfitness for Active Duty may not serve as a member of the Discharge Review Board for the same person (Supreme Court Decision 2008Du5186 (Jun. 26, 2008)).
 

D. Types of Resolutions


Upon review, the Committee decides whether the matter is ① a criminal case, ② a disciplinary case, or ③ not established. Specifically, it resolves whether the facts are found and, if so, whether they constitute sexual harassment, and it also resolves matters such as protective measures for the victim, measures concerning the actor and measures to prevent recurrence, and reports them to the commander.

 

4. Relationship between the Committee and the Disciplinary Committee


A. The Committee's Review Is Not a Mandatory Prerequisite for Discipline.


The Committee's review procedure is neither a mandatory procedure for handling sexual harassment or sexual violence matters nor a review that must be held before disciplinary proceedings (Seoul High Court (Chuncheon Bench) Decision 2025Nu180 (Sep. 18, 2025); Seoul High Court Decision 2024Nu48864 (Apr. 17, 2025)). Accordingly, a disciplinary resolution may be requested based on an investigation by the investigating department even without a review by the Committee.

 

B. The Committee's Resolution Does Not Bind the Disciplinary Committee.


The Committee's resolution is neither a prerequisite to a disciplinary resolution nor binding on the personnel committee (disciplinary committee) (Suwon High Court Decision 2020Nu10018 (Apr. 23, 2021)). Accordingly, even a matter the Committee found to be sexual harassment may be separately reviewed by the disciplinary committee, which may conclude that it is not sexual harassment; conversely, a matter the Committee did not recognize may be reviewed again by the disciplinary committee (Seoul High Court (Chuncheon Bench) Decision 2026Nu139 (Aug. 26, 2026)).

 

C. Defects in the Committee's Composition or Resolution and the Validity of Disciplinary Action


Even if there is a defect in the Committee's composition or resolution and the materials relating to its investigation and decision formed the basis of a disciplinary action, that alone does not render the disciplinary action procedurally unlawful. It is merely a question of the credibility of those materials (Jeonju District Court Decision 2024Guhap2269 (Feb. 12, 2025)).

 

D. The Disciplinary Authority's Duty to Request a Disciplinary Resolution


In sexual violence and similar cases, the disciplinary authority must request a disciplinary resolution unless there are justifiable grounds, and, if it considers the disciplinary committee's resolution too lenient compared with the disciplinary standards, must file a request for review or re-review. Under Article 59(7) of the Military Personnel Management Act, where the disciplinary authority considers the disciplinary committee's resolution to be too lenient, it may request a review or re-review by the disciplinary committee established at the next higher unit or agency to which a legal officer is assigned (Military Personnel Management Act, Article 59(7)).

 

5. Cases in Which the Committee's Findings Were Upheld or Rejected


A. Cases in Which Sexual Harassment Found by the Committee Was Upheld

 

1) Seoul Administrative Court Decision 2025Guhap56143 (Aug. 20, 2026) (Revocation of Demotion)

In a case where the plaintiff, team leader C at District B, repeatedly made sexual remarks and gestures toward a subordinate along with workplace harassment in the form of showing the subordinate another employee's salary agreement, the Committee found sexual harassment and the disciplinary committee resolved to demote the plaintiff. The court held that although there were some procedural defects in the disciplinary process (including a violation of the gender composition rule for the grievance review committee), they were not serious, and the demotion was justified on the grounds of the sexual harassment found alone (Seoul Administrative Court Decision 2025Guhap56143 (Aug. 20, 2026)).
 

2) Changwon District Court Decision 2025Guhap1673 (Jul. 23, 2026) (Revocation of Suspension)

In a case where the plaintiff repeatedly sent a subordinate complainant KakaoTalk messages containing comments on her appearance and expressions of personal feelings from August 2023 to November 2024, the Committee found "verbal sexual harassment," and the disciplinary committee resolved on a two-month suspension. The court held that neither the investigative agency's decision not to refer the case for prosecution nor some positive responses from the complainant negated the establishment of sexual harassment, and upheld the disciplinary action as lawful (Changwon District Court Decision 2025Guhap1673 (Jul. 23, 2026)).
 

3) Daejeon High Court Decision 2026Nu187 (Aug. 20, 2026) (Revocation of Suspension)

In a case where the plaintiff made sexual remarks about the victim E to F, rather than to E, the court considered that the plaintiff, E and F all worked as service members or military civilian employees in the same support section, together with the relationships among E, the plaintiff and F and the content of the plaintiff's remarks, and found sexual harassment, assessing the remarks as conduct creating an environment in which E could feel sexual humiliation or aversion (Daejeon High Court Decision 2026Nu187 (Aug. 20, 2026)).
 

4) Seoul High Court (Chuncheon Bench) Decision 2026Nu139 (Aug. 26, 2026) (Revocation of Disciplinary Action)

In this case, the Committee found items ㉮ and ㉰ to be sexual harassment, while the disciplinary committee recognized only item ㉮ (including touching of the thigh) as sexual harassment and imposed disciplinary action. Relying on the victim's consistent statements from the time of the initial investigation, the court found sexual harassment under item ㉮, including the touching of the thigh, and dismissed the plaintiff's appeal (Seoul High Court (Chuncheon Bench) Decision 2026Nu139 (Aug. 26, 2026)).

 

B. Cases in Which the Sexual Grievance Was Not Upheld


1) Seoul High Court (Chuncheon Bench) Decision 2025Nu180 (Sep. 18, 2025) (Revocation of Reprimand)

This case concerned disciplinary action taken without a review by the Committee. The court held that the Committee's review is not a mandatory prerequisite and rejected the claim of procedural defect. As to some of the disciplinary grounds, however, the plaintiff partly prevailed (the judgment was modified) (Seoul High Court (Chuncheon Bench) Decision 2025Nu180 (Sep. 18, 2025)).
 

2) Chuncheon District Court, Gangneung Branch Decision 2021Guhap30823 (Aug. 18, 2022) (Revocation of Pay Reduction)

As to the disciplinary ground that the plaintiff said to the victim in a car, "I held back back then," the court, on the premise that the defendant bears the burden of proving a sexual harassment disciplinary ground, held that the remark was insufficient to be regarded as conduct causing sexual humiliation or aversion, and did not recognize the disciplinary ground (Chuncheon District Court, Gangneung Branch Decision 2021Guhap30823 (Aug. 18, 2022)).

 

6. Burden of Proof in Sexual Harassment Cases


A. Burden of Proof in Actions to Revoke Disciplinary Action (Administrative Litigation)


In administrative litigation challenging the propriety of disciplinary action based on sexual harassment, the burden of proving the disciplinary grounds lies with the defendant (the disposing authority) asserting the lawfulness of the disposition. The required degree of proof, however, is not scientific proof; it suffices to prove a high degree of probability such that, considering all the evidence comprehensively in light of the rules of experience, the existence of a fact can be accepted (Supreme Court Decision 2017Du74702 (Apr. 12, 2018)).

 

B. Relationship between a Criminal Acquittal and Administrative or Civil Litigation


The mere fact that a defendant was acquitted of the charges in a criminal trial concerning the sexual harassment underlying the disciplinary grounds does not mean that the existence of the disciplinary grounds should be denied in administrative or civil litigation. This is because civil and criminal liability are governed by different principles in terms of their guiding ideals, burden of proof and required degree of proof (Supreme Court Decision 2017Du74702 (Apr. 12, 2018); Supreme Court Decision 2020Da281367 (Mar. 25, 2021)).

C. Burden of Proof Regarding Adverse Measures against Victimized Workers

 

Where a dispute arises from sexual harassment in the workplace, the employer must prove that any adverse measure taken against the victimized worker or others is unrelated to the sexual harassment or is justified (Supreme Court Decision 2016Da202947 (Dec. 22, 2017); Equal Employment Act, Article 30 (Burden of Proof)).

 

7. Liability for Damages When Sexual Harassment Is Established


Sexual harassment does not end with disciplinary or personnel consequences; liability for damages is also at issue.
 

A. Liability of the Perpetrator for Damages


The person who commits sexual harassment bears tort liability under Article 750 of the Civil Act. Whether sexual harassment is unlawful is not determined by limiting it to employment relationships or by classifying it as quid pro quo or hostile environment harassment; it is sufficient to treat it as a type of general tort and determine whether a tort is established based on the unlawfulness of the conduct (Supreme Court Decision 95Da39533 (Feb. 10, 1998)). Circumstances such as the victim being dismissed in retaliation for rejecting the perpetrator's harassment, or suffering undue interference with working conditions, are merely factors in calculating consolation money and do not determine whether a tort is established.



B. Liability for Damages When the Employer Is Also Responsible

 

The perpetrator's employer (including the State) bears vicarious liability under Article 756 of the Civil Act. Where an employee intentionally commits harmful conduct such as sexual harassment against another person, even if the conduct is not itself the performance of the employee's duties, if it is closely connected in time and place to the employer's business and occurs in the course of performing all or part of the employee's duties, or if the motive for the conduct is related to the handling of work, it is regarded as outwardly and objectively related to the performance of the employer's business, and vicarious liability is established (Supreme Court Decision 2021Da219529 (Sep. 16, 2021)). The employer is exempt from liability if it exercised due care in appointing and supervising the employee or if the damage would have occurred even with due care, but the employer bears the burden of asserting and proving such circumstances (Supreme Court Decision 97Da58538 (May 15, 1998)).

 

C. Separate Liability for Damages When an Employer Takes Adverse Measures against a Victim


Where an employer dismisses or takes other adverse measures against a worker who has been harmed by sexual harassment in the workplace, or who claims to have been harmed, this violates Article 14(6) of the Equal Employment Act and constitutes a tort under Article 750 of the Civil Act. The employer bears the burden of proving that the adverse measure against the victimized worker is unrelated to the sexual harassment or is justified (Supreme Court Decision 2016Da202947 (Dec. 22, 2017); Supreme Court Decision 2022Da273964 (Feb. 2, 2023)). Whether a measure is adverse is determined by considering comprehensively ① whether it was taken close in time to the raising of the sexual harassment issue, ② the background and process of the measure, ③ whether the reasons the employer gave for the measure existed before the issue was raised, and ④ whether it was unusual or discriminatory compared with past practice or similar cases (Supreme Court Decision 2016Da202947 (Dec. 22, 2017)).
 

We have reviewed above the procedure for resolving sexual grievances in the military and the statutes and case law on whether sexual harassment is established. For any questions, please consult an expert.

Profile photo of Attorney Sudong Lee

ONE LAW PARTNERS

Sudong LeeAttorney

T. +82-2-3019-5465

F. +82-2-3019-5498

E. sdlee@onelawpartners.com

View Profile ↗

The One You Need, The One You Trust

Built on expertise, trust and innovation, we have always sought better answers for our clients. At the end of every journey and at the heart of everything we value, there is always the client. We strive to be the one law firm our clients need and trust.

Key Practice Areas

Civil Litigation Commercial Litigation Construction & Real Estate Reconstruction & Redevelopment Administrative State Compensation Public Procurement & Bidding Corporate Criminal Search & Seizure Response Investigation & Trial Defense General Criminal Defense & Defense Industry

SNS Share 페이스북 공유하기트위터 공유하기네이버 공유하기
Related Members 1