Selected Cases
Development Contractor Represents Developer, Reduces Additional Payment Award to Approximately 36.7% of Liquidated Damages Claim
One Law Partners, LLC represented a system development company and successfully secured a reduction of liquidated damages and recognition of a deduction for the contract performance bond, limiting the principal amount additionally awarded to approximately 36.7% of the liquidated damages claimed. The firm also defended against separately asserted cost claims.
1. Case Overview
Following the termination of a system development contract, the client was sued by the project owner for liquidated damages and related costs. The claim was brought after the client had already returned the contract payments received and forfeited the contract performance bond.
In addition to liquidated damages, the project owner sought reimbursement for software purchase costs, server maintenance costs, and system maintenance and preservation expenses. The client thus faced additional financial exposure on top of the development costs already incurred and existing losses.
2. Key Issues
The case involved three principal issues.
First, whether the liquidated damages could be reduced in light of the contract performance process and the losses already borne by the client.
Second, whether the forfeited contract performance bond should be treated as a separate penalty or deducted from any additional damages awarded.
Third, whether the individual costs claimed by the project owner had an independent legal basis for recovery separate from the liquidated damages claim.
3. Key Defense Strategy
To minimize the client’s additional liability, One Law Partners, LLC addressed the appropriateness of the liquidated damages, the treatment of the forfeited bond, and the legal basis for the individual cost claims separately.
First, the firm presented evidence showing that the client had invested substantial resources in development and made efforts to perform the contract, while already bearing losses through the return of contract payments and forfeiture of the bond. Based on these circumstances, the firm argued that it would be excessive to enforce the liquidated damages amount as calculated under the contract without adjustment.
With respect to the contract performance bond, the firm refuted the plaintiff’s argument that the bond constituted a contractual penalty. The firm explained that the bond functioned as a pre-estimated amount of damages and argued that the forfeited amount should be reflected in and deducted from any additional damages award.
The firm also challenged the separate cost claims by examining whether they duplicated the pre-agreed damages and whether there was an independent basis for imposing liability on the client. Regarding system preservation costs, the firm argued that the preservation measures had been requested to secure evidence for litigation and were undertaken for the project owner’s own litigation purposes.
The court reduced the liquidated damages by 30% and deducted the forfeited contract performance bond from the reduced amount. As a result, the principal amount additionally awarded was limited to approximately 36.7% of the liquidated damages originally claimed, representing a reduction of approximately 63.3% compared to the claimed amount. The separately claimed costs were also denied.
4. Significance of the Case
The client was required to respond not only to the termination of the contract and the return of previously paid contract amounts, but also to substantial additional claims. One Law Partners, LLC reduced the client’s additional financial burden by ensuring that the losses already incurred and the contract performance bond were taken into account, while successfully contesting the legal basis for the separate cost claims.
This case demonstrates how a party can achieve a favorable result by identifying grounds for reducing contractual claims, deducting amounts that should be credited, and challenging duplicative claims, rather than accepting the claimed amount at face value.
※ The percentages are based on the principal amount awarded in the judgment compared to the principal liquidated damages amount claimed, excluding default interest and litigation costs.
-
Jin-Young Yang, Attorney | jyyang@onelawpartners.com
Joo-Seon Choi, Attorney | jschoi@onelawpartners.com
Song-Kyung Kim, Attorney | skkim@onelawpartners.com
TIF Team
-
Public Relations Team, One Law Partners, LLC | pr@onelawpartners.com

