errorPlease register the sub image.

Selected Cases

Construction & Real Estate,Administrative Law

Successful Opposition to Stay of Execution and Dismissal of Lawsuit Challenging Acceptance of Change-of-Building-Owner Notification

  • Date 2026.11.19
  • Hit 31

One Law Partners, LLC Successfully Defends Suspension of Execution Application and Secures Dismissal in Administrative Litigation Concerning Acceptance of Change of Building Owner Registration


1. Overview of the Case

This case involved administrative litigation arising from a dispute over the right to implement a building project and the change of the registered building owner, where the legal relationship between the original building owner and the transferee of the project implementation rights became a central issue.

The client was a business operator that had acquired rights related to a building project and filed a lawsuit against the original building owner seeking implementation of procedures for changing the registered building owner. The court subsequently rendered a judgment ordering the implementation of procedures to change the building owner registration to the client, and the judgment became final and conclusive.

Based on that final judgment, the client filed a notification of change of building-related parties with the competent administrative authority, which accepted the notification.

However, a third party claiming rights related to the building project separately from the original building owner filed a cancellation action against the administrative authority, asserting that the administrative authority's acceptance of the notification for the change of building owner registration was unlawful. The plaintiff argued that the administrative authority unlawfully accepted the client's notification for the change of building owner registration based on rights allegedly arising from a judicial settlement entered into with the original building owner and related legal relationships.

In this process, the most important issue for the client was not only the ultimate outcome of the principal action but also preventing disruption to the progress of the project that could result if the effectiveness of the acceptance disposition concerning the notification of change of building owner registration were suspended during the litigation.

On behalf of the client, which had secured its legal status through the administrative authority's acceptance of the notification of change of building owner registration, One Law Partners, LLC represented the intervenor supporting the defendant administrative authority in defending against the application for suspension of execution and the principal administrative action.


2. Key Issues

First, the issue was whether suspension of execution should be granted with respect to the disposition accepting the notification of change of building owner registration.

In administrative cancellation actions, an application may be filed seeking temporary suspension of the effect of the challenged administrative disposition before a judgment on the merits is rendered.

In this case, however, if suspension of execution were granted, the effectiveness of the disposition accepting the notification of change of building owner registration, which the client had obtained based on a final and conclusive judgment, would be suspended, creating a risk of significant adverse effects on the client's ability to proceed with the building project.

Accordingly, protecting the client's business status by maintaining the effectiveness of the disposition, regardless of the outcome of the principal action, became a critical objective.

Second, the issue was whether a third party that was not the direct recipient of the disposition accepting the notification of change of building owner registration had a legally protected interest to seek cancellation of that disposition.

The plaintiff asserted rights related to the building project based on contractual arrangements and a judicial settlement with the original building owner.

Because the plaintiff was not the direct recipient of the disposition accepting the notification of change of building owner registration, a key issue was whether the plaintiff had standing under the Administrative Litigation Act to seek cancellation of the disposition. In particular, the question was whether the contractual rights or economic interests asserted by the plaintiff constituted concrete legally protected interests directly protected by the Building Act or other related statutes.

3. Key Strategy and Response

One Law Partners, LLC responded proactively from the suspension of execution stage to prevent any disadvantage to the client's building project and, in the principal action, challenged the plaintiff's standing as a threshold issue.

At the suspension of execution stage, the firm focused on maintaining the effectiveness of the disposition accepting the notification of change of building owner registration.

The client had obtained a final and conclusive judgment in a lawsuit seeking implementation of procedures for changing the registered building owner and subsequently received the administrative authority's acceptance of its notification to change the building owner registration. Under these circumstances, suspension of the disposition's effectiveness would have caused direct harm to the client's ability to continue the building project.

By successfully opposing the application for suspension of execution, One Law Partners, LLC prevented suspension of the disposition and enabled the client to maintain its status as the registered building owner.

In the principal action, the firm raised a preliminary defense that the plaintiff lacked any legally protected interest to seek cancellation of the disposition.

Although a third party who is not the direct recipient of an administrative disposition may bring a cancellation action where a legally protected interest is infringed by the disposition, mere indirect, factual, or economic interests are insufficient to confer standing.

Based on these legal principles, One Law Partners, LLC carefully distinguished between the rights relating to the building project asserted by the plaintiff and the legal nature of the disposition accepting the notification of change of building owner registration. In particular, the firm emphasized that acceptance of a notification of change of building owner registration does not determine substantive ownership rights or contractual rights concerning a building. Rather, it is an administrative act accepting a change in building-related parties when the requirements prescribed by relevant laws and regulations are satisfied.

On this basis, the firm argued that even if the plaintiff could assert certain rights arising from contracts with the original building owner, such rights did not constitute legally protected interests that could be directly safeguarded through cancellation of the disposition accepting the client's notification of change of building owner registration.

The court accepted One Law Partners, LLC's preliminary defense. The court held that a building permit is not a mechanism for publicly disclosing changes in substantive property rights relating to a building, and that the disposition accepting the notification of change of building owner registration likewise does not directly confer or infringe legal interests relating to the rights asserted by the plaintiff.

The court further found that the rights related to the building project asserted by the plaintiff could not be regarded as concrete legally protected interests that would be directly protected by cancellation of the disposition at issue. Accordingly, on August 21, 2026, the Incheon District Court dismissed the action on the ground that the plaintiff lacked a legally protected interest to seek cancellation of the disposition accepting the notification of change of building owner registration, and ordered the plaintiff to bear litigation costs, including costs associated with the intervenor's participation in the proceedings.


4. Significance of the Case

This case demonstrates how a client's business status can be protected in an administrative dispute concerning a disposition accepting a notification of change of building owner registration through both a successful defense against an application for suspension of execution and a challenge to the plaintiff's standing in the principal action.

In particular, administrative litigation can be significantly affected by decisions on suspension of execution even before a judgment on the merits is rendered. In this case, the mere temporary suspension of the effectiveness of the disposition accepting the notification of change of building owner registration could have caused substantial harm to the client.

Taking these business risks into account, One Law Partners, LLC responded actively from the suspension of execution stage and achieved a practical outcome by preventing suspension and preserving the effectiveness of the disposition through which the client had secured its status as the registered building owner.

Furthermore, by carefully analyzing the legal nature of the disposition accepting the notification of change of building owner registration and the legal principles governing third-party standing, the firm successfully established that the plaintiff lacked a legally protected interest to seek cancellation of the disposition.

The case illustrates that the existence of contractual rights or economic interests relating to a building project does not, by itself, grant a third party standing to seek cancellation of a disposition accepting a notification of change of building owner registration.

Through the dual achievements of preventing suspension of execution and obtaining dismissal of the principal action, One Law Partners, LLC protected the client's legal status in relation to the building project and contributed to reducing uncertainty surrounding the project's continued progress.


-
Joong-Young Choi, Attorney | jychoi@onelawpartners.com
Su-Ji Lee, Attorney | sjlee2@onelawpartners.com
-
Public Relations Team, One Law Partners, LLC | pr@onelawpartners.com


SNS Share 페이스북 공유하기트위터 공유하기네이버 공유하기