errorPlease register the sub image.

Selected Cases

Intellectual Property Rights,TIF(Tech · IP · Fintech)

Injunction Granted Against Design Patent Infringement Involving Bag Products

  • Date 2026.11.19
  • Hit 61

ONE Law Partners represented the holder of a registered design for a bag product in preliminary injunction proceedings seeking to protect the client's design rights. The firm successfully obtained an injunction prohibiting the production, sale, and distribution of the allegedly infringing products based on the similarities between the registered design and the opposing party's products.
 
 
1. Case Overview
The client is the holder of a registered design for a bag product and had been selling products incorporating the registered design.
 
The registered design featured distinctive elements relating to the bag's main body, handles, internal storage components, and connecting structures. These elements reflected not only the bag's external appearance but also structural characteristics associated with storage and portability.
 
The client subsequently discovered that the opposing party was selling bag products with an appearance similar to the client's registered design through online sales channels.
 
The opposing party's products exhibited similarities to the registered design in terms of the bag's overall shape and proportions, the arrangement of the handles, and the connecting structures.
 
Believing that these products infringed its registered design rights, the client applied for a preliminary injunction to prohibit their production, sale, and distribution.
 
ONE Law Partners represented the client by comparing the registered design with the appearance of the opposing party's products and developing arguments concerning design infringement and the necessity of preliminary injunctive relief.
 
 
2. Key Legal Issues
First, whether the registered design and the opposing party's products created a similar overall aesthetic impression.
 
In determining whether design rights have been infringed, it is necessary to consider not only differences between individual design elements but also whether the designs create a similar overall aesthetic impression on ordinary consumers when viewed as a whole.
 
In this case, the principal points of comparison included the bag's overall shape and proportions, the configuration and attachment of its handles, and the structural features relating to folding and storage.
 
In particular, an important issue was whether minor differences in individual details were sufficient to distinguish the designs when their overall appearances shared prominent common features.
 
Second, whether the requirements for granting a preliminary injunction to prevent design infringement were satisfied.
 
A preliminary injunction against design infringement is a provisional legal remedy intended to prevent ongoing infringement before a final judgment is rendered in the main proceedings.
 
Accordingly, it was important to establish both the underlying right requiring protection and the necessity for interim relief, including the potential harm that could arise if the alleged infringement continued while the main proceedings were pending.
 
 
3. Legal Strategy and Representation
ONE Law Partners compared the drawings of the client's registered design with photographs and online sales materials relating to the opposing party's bag products, focusing on their shared visual characteristics and distinctive design features.
 
First, the firm conducted a comprehensive comparison of the overall shape and proportions of the registered design and the opposing party's products, including the arrangement of the handles and their connecting structures.
 
Particular emphasis was placed on the overall appearance created by the combination of the bag's principal design elements. The firm argued that minor differences in individual details did not necessarily negate the similarity between the designs as a whole.
 
The firm also presented evidence that the opposing party's products were being sold through online sales channels, demonstrating the risk that continued sales could result in ongoing infringement of the client's registered design rights.
 
On this basis, ONE Law Partners argued that it was necessary to suspend the production and sale of the opposing party's products even before a final judgment in the main proceedings.
 
As a result, on October 29, 2026, the Seoul Central District Court granted the application for a preliminary injunction against design infringement in part.
 
Subject to the applicant providing the security specified by the court, the court prohibited the opposing party from producing, using, transferring, leasing, or offering to transfer or lease the specified bag products.
 
The court dismissed the remainder of the application and ordered each party to bear its own litigation costs.
 
 
4. Significance of the Case
This case illustrates how preliminary injunctive relief can be used to prevent the continued distribution of products allegedly infringing a registered design, particularly where similar products are being marketed through online sales channels.
 
In design infringement disputes, differences in individual product elements do not necessarily preclude infringement if the designs create a similar overall aesthetic impression.
 
For consumer products such as bags, the overall shape and proportions, handle configurations, and storage structures may be important factors contributing to the visual impression of the design. It is therefore essential to evaluate the registered design and the allegedly infringing product as a whole.
 
Furthermore, where potentially infringing products continue to be distributed through online sales channels, seeking a preliminary injunction separately from the main infringement proceedings may provide an effective means of preventing further harm to the rights holder.
 
By focusing on the visual similarities between the registered design and the opposing party's products, as well as the necessity of interim relief, ONE Law Partners successfully obtained a preliminary injunction restricting the production, sale, and distribution of products incorporating a similar design, thereby contributing to the protection of the client's registered design rights.


Contact
Kyung Hwan Kim | Attorney at Law
khkim@onelawpartners.com
Seul Gi Oh | Attorney at Law
skoh@onelawpartners.com
ONE Law Partners | Public Relations Team
pr@onelawpartners.com


SNS Share 페이스북 공유하기트위터 공유하기네이버 공유하기