Selected Cases
Product Development Company Obtains Preliminary Injunction Against OEM Manufacturer Prohibiting Manufacturing and Sales
One Law Partners, LLC represented a product development company and the rights holders and obtained a preliminary injunction ordering an OEM manufacturer to cease the manufacture and sale of the relevant products and requiring related items to be placed in the custody of a court enforcement officer on the grounds of unauthorized use of the clients’ achievements.
1. Case Overview
The clients invested in product design and production preparation before launching their product and outsourced manufacturing to an external OEM company. The product had been sold based on its distinctive structure and user convenience, which differentiated it from existing products.
However, the manufacturer that had been entrusted with production began selling products with a similar structure and competing with the clients. The clients faced the risk that not only their development costs and efforts, but also the goodwill and business opportunities accumulated through sales of the product, would be infringed.
Accordingly, the clients filed an application for a preliminary injunction seeking to prohibit the manufacture and sale of the opposing party’s products and to place the related items in the custody of a court enforcement officer.
2. Key Issues
First, the issue was whether the clients’ product constituted a protectable achievement created through substantial investment and effort. This required consideration of the product development process, distinctions from existing products, and the value established in the marketplace.
Second, the issue was whether the opposing party’s manufacture and sale constituted an act of unfair competition through the unauthorized use of such achievement. The similarities in the structures of the two products, together with the OEM business relationship, competitive relationship, and likelihood of confusion, were examined.
Third, the parties disputed whether there was a risk of irreparable harm to the clients if sales continued while awaiting a judgment on the merits, namely, whether there was a need for preliminary injunctive relief.
3. Key Strategies and Court Decision
One Law Partners, LLC, acting on behalf of the clients, argued that the opposing party had been unlawfully using the achievements created through the clients’ investment and efforts in developing the product. The firm also asserted that the opposing party had violated contractual provisions relating to the production and supply of similar products.
In addition, the firm sought prompt injunctive relief by emphasizing that the opposing party’s sales were affecting the clients’ revenue and creating a risk of irreparable harm to consumer recognition and business opportunities.
The court recognized the product as a protectable achievement based on the product design, mold development, structural characteristics, and the goodwill accumulated after its launch. Taking into account the fact that the opposing party had manufactured the clients’ product as an OEM supplier and the structural similarities between the competing products, the court determined that the conduct constituted unauthorized use of the clients’ achievement.
The court also recognized the necessity of preserving the status quo in light of continuing sales and declining revenue. Subject to the provision of security, the court prohibited the manufacture and sale of the relevant products and ordered that finished goods, semi-finished goods, packaging materials, and promotional advertising materials for sale be placed in the custody of a court enforcement officer.
4. Significance of the Case
This decision is a case in which injunctive relief was granted against a manufacturer that used the achievements embodied in a product developed by the clients to sell competing products.
One Law Partners, LLC sought the preliminary injunction based not only on the appearance of the product but also on the clients’ development achievements, business relationship, and commercial damages. The court recognized both the unauthorized use of the achievement and the necessity of preservation and accordingly ordered a prohibition on manufacturing and sales, together with the custody of related items by a court enforcement officer.
-
Jin-Young Yang, Attorney | jyyang@onelawpartners.com
Jean Yun, Attorney | jyun@onelawpartners.com
TIF Team
-
Public Relations Team, One Law Partners, LLC | pr@onelawpartners.com

